HISTORY AND OFF-BROADWAY

What Is the #1 Broadway Show of All Time?

If “number one” means the most Broadway performances, the answer is The Phantom of the Opera. If you mean the highest Broadway box office gross or the most Tony wins, the leader changes.

Checked

Three ways to answer

MeasureLeaderWhat the record counts
Broadway performancesThe Phantom of the Opera13,981 regular performances in its original Broadway run.
Broadway box office grossThe Lion KingGuinness reports $2.15 billion in Broadway box office receipts through November 2, 2025.
Tony wins by one productionThe Producers12 wins for the 2001 production, including Best Musical.

What the comparisons tell you

Performance count measures how long a particular run lasted. Gross receipts are nominal ticket sales, with no adjustment here for ticket price changes or inflation. Tony wins count awards in a season and are affected by which categories a production could enter. Use the record that answers the question you care about.

Sources